- Forums > Religion & Philosophy > Da Vinci Code and Muslims
5/31/2006 7:52 PM (28 Comments)
- Tousif
- 24, India
Should Muslims support Catholics demanding a ban on Da Vinci Code movie? Or should they stay neutral? Well, some Muslim leaders in India and Canada have already issued religious decrees seeking a ban on the movie. In fact, a few Muslim leaders from Bombay went even further threatening violent demonstrations if the movie was released.
What is Da Vinci code and why should one take it seriously even though it is a book of fiction. The issue at hand is not the literary style and the descriptive narratives or the mystery it weaves around its characters, it is the distortion of some of the historical facts around the character of Prophet Jesus (peace be upon him - ), which is at the center of the controversy. The book and the movie deal with a number of issues related with faith, history and culture. They definitely erode the foundations of faith for both protestants and Catholics as they present Jesus in a manner that an average Christian is not familiar with.
From the perspectives of Muslims, some of the assumptions reinforce their own religious views on Jesus , while the others are contrary to Islamic beliefs.
For instance, on four issues, Da Vinci code essentially presents a view point similar to that one finds in the Quran as well as in Muslim history. The book and the movie assert that Jesus was not viewed as God until the fourth century. Muslim historians concur with that assertion. The movie highlights the role of emperor Constantine in projecting Jesus as God and Muslims agree with that analysis. The movie suggests that the Roman emperor unified Christians on the divinity of Jesus and forced a version of New Testament upon them that suited this ideology. Muslims' view is slightly different. They argue that it was the split within the Church that caused this issue to dominate the Christian scene and priests rather than politicians influenced the decision of the Roman emperor. The final point on which both Muslim and the author of the book agree is that the message of Jesus was distorted to suit the will of Emperor of Rome and his supporters.
However, when the movie talks about the character of Prophet Jesus, Muslim viewpoint does not agree with the views of the author. Muslims support Christians claim that the movie distorts the figure of Prophet Jesus . The movie shows that Jesus and Mary Magdelene married secretly. Muslims do not agree with this assertion and believe that even if he did it would not diminish his character. The movie further says that the two had a daughter whose name was Sarah and whose progeny still survives in Europe. Muslims reject this claim as well.
The argument is simple. Those who are revered by billions of people all over the world can not be subject to fictional distortions. Religious figures should be spared from harsh criticism by those who rely only on selected and subjective sources.
The movie also asserts that the Catholic church is involved in murders and assassinations of those who knew of this secret and wanted to expose it. Obviously, it is an assertion that exists in the imagination of the author. The second issue is that the Church is aware of the truth and is deliberately trying to cover it up. Both assumptions are based on fiction and both are meant to create more confusion.
The film and the book supporters present the first amendment in support of their work. In their zeal of freedom of speech they fail to recognize that freedom does not give them a license to assassinate the character of religious icons. The movie is promoting fictional falsehood about the character of Jesus .
We hope that the true nature and mission of Jesus will bring the essence of the Lord of all Creation into our lives.
takwn from: http://www.islamicity.com/articles/Articles.asp?ref=IC0605-3001
What is Da Vinci code and why should one take it seriously even though it is a book of fiction. The issue at hand is not the literary style and the descriptive narratives or the mystery it weaves around its characters, it is the distortion of some of the historical facts around the character of Prophet Jesus (peace be upon him - ), which is at the center of the controversy. The book and the movie deal with a number of issues related with faith, history and culture. They definitely erode the foundations of faith for both protestants and Catholics as they present Jesus in a manner that an average Christian is not familiar with.
From the perspectives of Muslims, some of the assumptions reinforce their own religious views on Jesus , while the others are contrary to Islamic beliefs.
For instance, on four issues, Da Vinci code essentially presents a view point similar to that one finds in the Quran as well as in Muslim history. The book and the movie assert that Jesus was not viewed as God until the fourth century. Muslim historians concur with that assertion. The movie highlights the role of emperor Constantine in projecting Jesus as God and Muslims agree with that analysis. The movie suggests that the Roman emperor unified Christians on the divinity of Jesus and forced a version of New Testament upon them that suited this ideology. Muslims' view is slightly different. They argue that it was the split within the Church that caused this issue to dominate the Christian scene and priests rather than politicians influenced the decision of the Roman emperor. The final point on which both Muslim and the author of the book agree is that the message of Jesus was distorted to suit the will of Emperor of Rome and his supporters.
However, when the movie talks about the character of Prophet Jesus, Muslim viewpoint does not agree with the views of the author. Muslims support Christians claim that the movie distorts the figure of Prophet Jesus . The movie shows that Jesus and Mary Magdelene married secretly. Muslims do not agree with this assertion and believe that even if he did it would not diminish his character. The movie further says that the two had a daughter whose name was Sarah and whose progeny still survives in Europe. Muslims reject this claim as well.
The argument is simple. Those who are revered by billions of people all over the world can not be subject to fictional distortions. Religious figures should be spared from harsh criticism by those who rely only on selected and subjective sources.
The movie also asserts that the Catholic church is involved in murders and assassinations of those who knew of this secret and wanted to expose it. Obviously, it is an assertion that exists in the imagination of the author. The second issue is that the Church is aware of the truth and is deliberately trying to cover it up. Both assumptions are based on fiction and both are meant to create more confusion.
The film and the book supporters present the first amendment in support of their work. In their zeal of freedom of speech they fail to recognize that freedom does not give them a license to assassinate the character of religious icons. The movie is promoting fictional falsehood about the character of Jesus .
We hope that the true nature and mission of Jesus will bring the essence of the Lord of all Creation into our lives.
takwn from: http://www.islamicity.com/articles/Articles.asp?ref=IC0605-3001
5/31/2006 8:07 PMRe: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
6/1/2006 1:54 AMRe: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Eleany
24, Cebu City, Philippines
But they are banning it here in the Philippines.
Though it passed the Movie Regulatory Board and was shown in movie houses, the church here made such an uproar that they pulled it out of theaters.
And I do agree with you, banning it would be pointless.
Once something is banned or prohibited, it would only fuel the public's desire to see it.
Besides there are a lot of ways and means that they could view the movie because so many bootleg copies are available here. While many could just download it *whether legally or not* online.
Though it passed the Movie Regulatory Board and was shown in movie houses, the church here made such an uproar that they pulled it out of theaters.
And I do agree with you, banning it would be pointless.
Once something is banned or prohibited, it would only fuel the public's desire to see it.
Besides there are a lot of ways and means that they could view the movie because so many bootleg copies are available here. While many could just download it *whether legally or not* online.
6/1/2006 2:17 AMRe: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
kat
24, United States
lol didn't know that, is Perdue deceased? If not he should get his share of dough ha. Ya its too bad people forget.
Watch people walk around after reading the novel saying "well personalllly we think he was married and and andyaddy yadda "
Thats why i hate the book. I don't care how interesting it is. If its based on a real person , then it should be factual. Or else its just a book full of lies that people clearly are going to associate with Jesus. Ah well...nothing we can do about it now except protest.
Watch people walk around after reading the novel saying "well personalllly we think he was married and and andyaddy yadda "
Thats why i hate the book. I don't care how interesting it is. If its based on a real person , then it should be factual. Or else its just a book full of lies that people clearly are going to associate with Jesus. Ah well...nothing we can do about it now except protest.
6/1/2006 2:44 AMRe: Re: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Eleany
24, Cebu City, Philippines
He is very much alive and well...
And I think there is already a court case going on with regards to that. Dan Brown being sued for plagiarism.
I have said this before, sometimes people would immediately believe whatever it is they read without even exerting any effort to find out if its true or not.
Another example would be, a lot of people actually believe Peter Pan is real. roflmao
And I think there is already a court case going on with regards to that. Dan Brown being sued for plagiarism.
I have said this before, sometimes people would immediately believe whatever it is they read without even exerting any effort to find out if its true or not.
Another example would be, a lot of people actually believe Peter Pan is real. roflmao
6/1/2006 3:05 PMRe: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Paul
39, Sheffield, United Kingdom
There was such a case going on. It failed; Brown was cleared of the plagiarism charge.
5/31/2006 8:15 PMRe: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Paul
39, Sheffield, United Kingdom
"The argument is simple. Those who are revered by billions of people all over the world can not be subject to fictional distortions. Religious figures should be spared from harsh criticism by those who rely only on selected and subjective sources."
This, for starters, is absolutely unacceptable. Applying it to a work of fiction is not only unacceptable, it's also bloody stupid.
IT'S NOT REAL! IT'S ALL MADE UP! He could write about Jesus being a homosexual rent-boy who sold his ass for three shekels a ride, and it still wouldn't matter any, because it's NOT SUPPOSED TO BE TAKEN SERIOUSLY.
This, for starters, is absolutely unacceptable. Applying it to a work of fiction is not only unacceptable, it's also bloody stupid.
IT'S NOT REAL! IT'S ALL MADE UP! He could write about Jesus being a homosexual rent-boy who sold his ass for three shekels a ride, and it still wouldn't matter any, because it's NOT SUPPOSED TO BE TAKEN SERIOUSLY.
5/31/2006 8:52 PMRe: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Tousif
24, Tellicherry, India
may god have mercy on u.... we respect and love all our religious figures very much.... it pains to see them being dishonored and disrespected - be it in a work of fiction or not... just how wud u feel if someone said something really degrading about ur mother?...
5/31/2006 10:18 PMRe: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
5/31/2006 10:21 PMRe: Re: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
6/1/2006 11:44 AMRe: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Sandra
25, Hamburg, Germany
banning a movie because it has a delicate topic is so medieval. if we start that, what else are we going to ban? star wars? because it shows aliens and we don´t know wether tehy exist or not?
after all the da vinci code is fiction. I think it´s a good story because it makes people think before they believe everything.
thanks god I live in germany.
after all the da vinci code is fiction. I think it´s a good story because it makes people think before they believe everything.
thanks god I live in germany.
6/2/2006 5:28 AMRe: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Eleany
24, Cebu City, Philippines
Ha! That is the very reason why im not a fan of star wars.
He's ugly! looooooool
He's ugly! looooooool
6/2/2006 5:45 AMRe: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
.
25, Canada
What? He's a babe magnet.
6/2/2006 5:51 AMRe: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
Eleany
24, Cebu City, Philippines
6/2/2006 5:53 AMRe: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Da Vinci Code and Muslims
.
25, Canada
This is probably the wrong place for us to be promoting pipe. Haha









5/31/2006 8:15 PMRe: Da Vinci Code and Muslims